Pinal County and the Regional Transportation Authority Respond to Goldwater Institute Lawsuit
By: Pinal County
FLORENCE, AZ — Responding to the Goldwater Institute’s lawsuit challenging voter-approved transportation sales tax, Pinal County and the Regional Transportation Authority (RTA) filing informs the court that the lawsuit is untimely and without merit.
The case is pending before Judge Chris Whitten in the Maricopa County Superior Court.
After a widely-publicized and debated Special Election on November 7, 2017, Pinal County voters approved a Regional Transportation Plan through Proposition 416 to meet the critical infrastructure needs created by the region’s rapid economic growth and development.
To pay for the plan, voters concurrently approved a transportation excise tax through Proposition 417. The rates and methods for applying the tax were described in the materials sent to voters before the election and the tax goes into effect on April 1, 2018. The sales tax will fund the transportation plan for 20 years.
Days before its effective date, the Goldwater Institute seeks to stop the collection of this voter-approved tax. The lawsuit wants to halt all necessary infrastructure improvements, based on unsubstantiated claims of voter confusion during the election and legally weak arguments regarding the constitutionality of Proposition 417. As indicated in the filing, these arguments not only should have been raised before the election, but also lack merit and undermine the voters’ voice when enacting Proposition 417.
“This lawsuit is nothing more than a post-election attack by those who failed to convince voters to oppose the transportation tax at the election,” said Board of Supervisors Chairman Todd House. “The voters spoke clearly about the need for improved transportation infrastructure in the Pinal region last November while also expressing their willingness to pay an additional sales tax that amounts to about $7.33 per month per household.”
RTA Member and Supervisors Vice-Chairman Pete Rios commented, “We cannot move forward with the transportation improvement until this lawsuit is over and will urge the court to dismiss the suit as quickly as possible.”